Considering making a move? Perhaps your next home could be here, where you can focus on building a new chapter in your life story [Previous response, 38]. Your next chapter could be your best chapter [Previous response], and exploring the Plum Creek Subdivision in Muskego, Wisconsin, is a great place to start. Whether you're looking to find your perfect new home or selling to move on to what's next, we're here to guide you through this exciting transition.

The Plum Creek subdivision includes Plum Creek and Plum Creek Addn. #1, and Plum Creek East. These areas are located within the City of Muskego in Waukesha County, Wisconsin.

Location & Physical Geography

Plum Creek is known for its winding roads and desirable cul-de-sacs, which feature mature trees and are even home to at least two donkeys.

An appealing aspect of living here is the proximity to nature and community resources. A private bike path connects the Plum Creek and Plum Creek East developments. The subdivision is also within walking distance to several key locations:

  • Muskego County Park features a high-quality hardwood forest, designated a state scientific area and State Natural Area, and is noted for astounding numbers of spring flowers in early May.
  • Muskego High School
  • Alpine (Bowling) Lanes 
  • Muskego bike trail

Idle Isle Park, also in Muskego, offers a beach and pier and is a great place for walking, with trees and benches.

Life in Greater Muskego

Muskego offers a vibrant community setting. In 2023, Muskego had a population of about 25.2k people. The median household income was $116,361, with a high homeownership rate of 87.6% in 2023. 

You can visit the Muskego, WI | Data USA website for more detailed demographic information.

There are many things to do in the greater Muskego area:

  • Parks: Including Muskego County Park, Idle Isle Park, Veterans Memorial Park, Kurth Park, Denoon Park, Bluhm Farm Park, and Lions Park.
  • Entertainment & Activities: These include Lotza Fun Room (a play experience), Eagle Park Brewing & Distilling (breweries), Schultz Resort Rod & Gun Club (shooting ranges), and Psychic of Muskego (games and entertainment).
  • Dining & Nightlife: Popular spots include Mug'z Pub & Grill, DANNY HASKELL'S Pub & Grill, and AJ's Bar & Grill.
  • Shopping: Options like Kohl's (department stores) and other specialty shops.
  • Spas: Glo Salon & Spa, L Spa, and Arizona Spa.

The Muskego Area Chamber of Commerce serves local businesses and organizations in Muskego, Big Bend, the Town of Norway, and Wind Lake. It supports community events and offers visitor information about lake communities and activities.

Understanding the Homeowners Association (HOA)

Plum Creek, Plum Creek Addn. #1 and Plum Creek East are subject to Deed Restrictions. These restrictions establish a general plan for the use, occupancy, and enjoyment of the properties, intended for the mutual benefit of owners. They are in force perpetually, running with the land.

The PLUM CREEK HOMEOWNERS ASSOCIATION governs the deed restrictions.  Committee members are responsible for maintaining improvements like ponds (including removing silt build-up or algae) and enforcing regulations. Its powers include maintaining Common Areas, entering into contracts, and levying assessments.

Sampling from Deed Restrictions:

The Deed Restrictions cover various aspects of property use and building within the subdivision. Key areas include:

  • Building Types: Primarily single-family residences restricted to one story, one and a half story, two-story, or split-level, with minimum square footage requirements. Specific minimum living square footage rules apply to Duplex and Eight-Family lots in Plum Creek East, with architecture subject to approval.
  • Garages: Single-family homes must have a minimum of two attached garages, with a maximum size specified (900 sq ft). Attached garages are also required for duplex units (two-car) and eight-family units (one-car).
  • Approval Process: All building plans and the exterior design of each dwelling unit require written approval from the Developer (or appropriate party) before applying for a building permit. Basic site features such as fences, garden structures, satellite dishes, additions, or other temporary or permanent structures also need prior written approval.
  • Use Restrictions: Restrictions include prohibitions on outside storage of items deemed unsightly (like boats, trailers, campers, or other vehicles) and above-ground swimming pools. All driveways shall be paved within one year of occupancy.
  • Maintenance Requirements: One outdoor electric lamppost with photoelectric controls must be installed in a location designated by the Developer at the time of construction of a residence building, and maintained by the lot owner in a proper operating manner. If the lamppost is not maintained, the Association can perform the maintenance and assess the cost against the lot owner. Each lot owner must strictly adhere to and finish grading their lot following the Master Grading Plan.

You can often find the Deed Restrictions document on the City of Muskego's website at this URL: . Be aware that City of Muskego's website may not have the absolute latest version, as these documents are subject to change. Always seek the most current version directly from the appropriate municipal office or by contacting the Homeowners Association.

Ready to Explore Plum Creek?

The necessary information is crucial when considering a move. Whether you want to find your place in Plum Creek or start on your next adventure by selling your current home here, we are ready to assist.  You can explore what might be available for sale and get instant access to the area's latest market report, which includes sales and demographic trends.


Residents can request access to the private neighborhood Facebook Page.

Deed restrictions can be found at the city of Muskego Website.

sign - plum creek
plum creek home 1
plum creek - cul de sac - Copy

Recent Sales

Want the full market report for Plum Creek?

We want to ensure that you have all the information needed to make the best decisions when it comes to your home goals. When you enter your info below you will get instant access to the area's latest market report, complete with sales and demographic trends.

Plum Creek
Market Report

Around The Area

Browse through the top rated businesses that Plum Creek has to offer!

Local News & Advice

Read helpful resources and articles related to the area.

Things you should know about appraisal gaps

Things you should know about appraisal gaps

What is a CMA?

What is a CMA?

Preparing a Home For Sale

Preparing a Home For Sale